News

Public · Published

Why F&O curbs may be backfiring: Nithin Kamath says just 10% of option buyers profit

Zerodha founder Nithin Kamath said about 10% of individual options buyers are profitable, versus roughly 40% of options sellers and 50% of futures traders, and warned that steps to curb derivatives speculation may push retail traders toward riskier behaviour.

Published:

Updated:

What happened

Zerodha founder Nithin Kamath said about 10% of individual options buyers are profitable, versus roughly 40% of options sellers and 50% of futures traders, and warned that steps to curb derivatives speculation may push retail traders toward riskier behaviour.

Confirmed

Global impact / market context

Higher securities transaction tax, which is a tax on trades, plus bigger contract sizes and many weekly expiries can nudge retail traders away from futures and into repeated options buying, where losses build over time despite limited loss per trade.

Analyst inference

If curbs push activity into riskier options buying rather than reduce speculation, brokers and exchanges may see different trading volumes and revenue, while regulators face pressure to redesign rules so retail traders are not steered toward worse outcomes.

Analyst inference

What to watch

  1. Kamath said it is too early to assess profitability in the margin trading facility, a product that lets traders borrow to buy shares, because it is relatively new. Confirmed
  2. Regulators could review securities transaction tax on futures, contract sizes and weekly expiries together, since Kamath linked these to the shift toward options buying. Proposed
  3. Watch whether broker profitability data shows options buyers improving or worsening, which would indicate if current curbs change retail trading behaviour as intended. Analyst inference

Evidence

  • Original source link unavailable