News
Public · Published
Casey's Wants a Bigger Slice of the Pizza Market. Why Fast Food Chains Are Worried. — Barrons.com
Casey's General Stores is introducing square, thick-crust pan pizzas at nearly 3,000 locations in 19 states. The company says nearly 80% of the small towns it serves lack a nearby national pan-pizza option. Casey's stock rose nearly 3% early Monday before giving back much of that gain.
Published:
Updated:
What happened
Casey's General Stores is introducing square, thick-crust pan pizzas at nearly 3,000 locations in 19 states. The company says nearly 80% of the small towns it serves lack a nearby national pan-pizza option. Casey's stock rose nearly 3% early Monday before giving back much of that gain.
Confirmed
Global impact / market context
Casey's is already the fifth-largest pizza chain by location count. Adding pan pizza at existing stores lets it sell more food without building new restaurants, taking sales from chains like Papa John's, whose North American comparable sales fell 8.3% in its latest reported quarter.
Analyst inference
Budget-conscious Americans are cutting restaurant spending, and quick-service pizza sales dropped 0.3% in 2025, per Technomic. Convenience stores are becoming stronger competitors to fast-food restaurants, pressuring traditional pizza chains already reporting weaker comparable sales, which means sales at stores open at least a year.
Analyst inference
What to watch
- Watch whether Casey's pan pizza lifts prepared food and dispensed beverage revenue, which already surged 63% over the past five fiscal years, with pizza remaining a major part. Confirmed
- Watch Papa John's and Pizza Hut comparable sales for signs that convenience-store pizza is pulling away budget diners, since Papa John's North American comparable sales fell 8.3% in its latest reported quarter. Analyst inference
- Watch Casey's rollout progress across its nearly 3,000 stores in 19 states, since wider availability of pan pizza could determine whether the launch meaningfully adds prepared food sales. Proposed
Evidence
- Original source link unavailable